The appeal, dated April 10, 2026, comes after the judgment in Suit No. LD/18843MFHR/2025: Falana v. Meta Platforms, Inc., where Justice O. A. Oresanya ruled in Falana’s favour and awarded him $25,000 in damages over a video said to have infringed on his rights.
Meta’s legal team, led by Mofesomo Tayo-Oyetibo, SAN, filed a Notice of Appeal outlining eight grounds, contesting both the legal reasoning and procedures adopted by the High Court.
A key issue in the appeal is whether the matter should have been handled as a fundamental rights enforcement case. Meta argued that the court was wrong to treat it under the Fundamental Rights (Enforcement Procedure) Rules, insisting the claims were rooted in alleged false publication and reputational harm.
The company maintained that such issues fall under defamation law, not constitutional rights enforcement, and therefore the court lacked the jurisdiction to hear the case in that context.
Meta also disputed the court’s finding of liability based on the doctrine of undisclosed principal, arguing there was no proof of any principal-agent relationship between it and the publisher of the video, AfriCare Health Centre.
It stressed that the content was produced and uploaded by an independent third party, and not by Meta, adding that as a digital platform, it neither created nor exercised editorial control over the material.
Furthermore, the company challenged the ruling that it breached provisions of the Nigeria Data Protection Act, particularly Section 24(1)(a) and (e), arguing it was wrongly classified as a data controller.
Meta insisted there was no evidence showing it determined how or why the personal data in question was processed.
The firm also objected to the $25,000 damages awarded to Falana, describing the decision as unjustified and urging the appellate court to overturn both the award and the entire judgment.
In addition, Meta raised concerns about the fairness of the trial, alleging it was denied a fair hearing. It claimed the court introduced and ruled on certain issues on its own without allowing both parties to address them, and failed to properly consider key aspects of its defence before delivering judgment.