Nigerian National Loses Fresh Legal Battle Over 20-Year-Old Arrest And Detention In South Africa

Published

South Africa’s Supreme Court of Appeal has dismissed an application by Nigerian national Sunday Okoro seeking to revive a R5.41 million compensation claim against the country’s Minister of Police over his arrest and detention following the discovery of a dead man in a Durban apartment.

The decision, delivered on November 17, came after the court rejected Okoro’s request for reconsideration, following earlier unsuccessful attempts to secure permission to appeal the judgment dismissing his claim.

Okoro was arrested without a warrant on July 3, 2002, after police discovered a man hanging by a bedsheet in the shower of room 7 at Evaleigh Court in Durban. He had reportedly rented the room a few days before the discovery.

He remained in custody until November 29, 2002, when the charges against him were withdrawn.

Following his release, Okoro instituted legal proceedings against the Minister of Police, alleging that his arrest and detention were unlawful. He sought R5.41 million in damages for the losses and suffering he claimed to have experienced. The amount was estimated at approximately ₦430 million in the report.

However, the KwaZulu-Natal High Court in Durban dismissed the claim with costs, ruling that police had reasonable grounds to suspect Okoro of involvement in the man’s death and that his arrest and detention were lawful.

After both the High Court and the Supreme Court of Appeal refused his applications for leave to appeal, Okoro approached the president of the appeal court, seeking a reconsideration of the matter.

The application was considered by a three-member panel comprising Acting Judges of Appeal Mjali and Molitsoane, alongside Judge of Appeal Nicholls. Acting Judge Molitsoane and Judge Nicholls formed the majority that rejected the application with costs.

During the proceedings, the court heard that Warrant Officers Allen Mark Naidu and Sunil Seosunker were conducting crime-prevention operations in Durban’s Point area when they encountered Okoro outside Evaleigh Court.

Naidu told the court that Okoro entered the building after noticing their police vehicle, prompting the officers to follow him inside. He said he later observed Okoro emerging from room 7 in a distressed condition while repeatedly calling out the name Francine.

According to the officer’s testimony, Okoro asked them to accompany him into the room, where they discovered the man’s body hanging in the shower. Naidu said the deceased was cold and stiff, with no detectable pulse.

The officer further testified that he suspected the hanging had been staged to conceal an unlawful death. He explained that the position of the man’s feet, which were not sufficiently close to the shower ledge, raised doubts about whether the ledge had been used to carry out a suicide.

In dismissing the claim, the court found no evidence that police officers had misled prosecutors or deliberately withheld or misrepresented information to ensure Okoro remained in custody.

It also concluded that there was no legal basis for holding the Minister of Police responsible for Okoro’s continued detention after his first appearance in court, leaving the Nigerian national with another setback in his long-running legal battle.

Author:
BushRadio

Comments

0 comments

    Join the discussion

    Use a display name or leave it blank to comment as Anonymous. Email is not required.