Court Admits Disputed Confessions In Jonathan Aides’ Jewellery Theft Trial
A Bayelsa State High Court has admitted into evidence the confessional statements of eight former domestic staff of ex–First Lady Patience Jonathan in the ongoing trial over the alleged theft of jewellery valued at hundreds of millions of naira, despite serious claims that the confessions were obtained through torture.
The ruling followed a “trial within trial” conducted by the court to determine whether the statements were made voluntarily by the accused persons.
Sources who observed Friday’s proceedings told SaharaReporters that the prosecution finally closed its case after nearly six years of delays.
“After six years, the prosecution has finally closed its case. The defence will now open its own case,” a family member of one of the defendants said.
However, the source expressed concern over the court’s decision to admit the disputed confessions, despite testimonies alleging that they were extracted under duress while the suspects were in police custody.
“The shocking part is that the court admitted confessional statements that were forcefully obtained from the eight defendants,” the source said. “They were beaten and tortured by the police. Some of the statements were even written by police officers in 2019 and the defendants were compelled to sign them.”
According to the source, the prosecution repeatedly stalled proceedings over the years, only concluding its presentation of evidence last Friday.
The eight defendants are among a group of 15 domestic workers initially charged in connection with the alleged theft from Mrs Jonathan’s residence in 2019. The number of accused persons was reduced following the death of one defendant, Sahabi Liman, in 2025.
Those still standing trial include Williams Alami, Vincent Olabiyi, Ebuka Cosmos, John Dashe, Tamunokuro Abaku, Emmanuel Aginwa, Erema Deborah, Precious Kingsley, Tamunosiki Achese, Salomi Wareboka, Sunday Reginald, Boma Oba, Vivian Golden and Emeka Benson.
The trial has been characterised by repeated adjournments and prolonged inactivity, with long stretches during which no court sessions were held.
Torture allegations, no accountability
During earlier hearings, several defendants testified that they were unlawfully detained, tortured and denied access to legal representation.
One defendant, Vivian Golden, told the court she was suspended and flogged after refusing to sign a confessional statement.
Other defendants named a police officer identified as “O.C. Chris” and a Chief Security Officer, Colin Otutu, as key figures in the alleged acts of torture.
Despite these allegations and what the defendants described as credible evidence of abuse, SaharaReporters found that no police officer has been investigated or charged in connection with the claims.
Mrs Jonathan has also not been summoned or questioned during the course of the trial.
Defence sources further accused the former First Lady’s legal team — led by Ige Asemudara and Samuel Chinedu Maduba — of deliberately prolonging the case through procedural applications and repeated delays.
The prolonged prosecution has already had fatal consequences. In September 2025, SaharaReporters reported the death of Sahabi Liman, one of the original defendants, following a long illness.
Liman, who was arrested in 2019, was granted bail three years later on health grounds after his condition deteriorated while in custody at the Okaka Correctional Centre in Yenagoa. His son said his health continued to decline after his release, and he later died at a hospital in Port Harcourt, Rivers State.